Saturday, May 20, 2023

What About a Constitutional Amendment for Over-Regulated, Over-Legislated California

 

In 2022 the California Legislature passed nearly 1200 bills, 997 of which were signed into laws by Governor Newsome. Some of these laws fix issues with laws that were previously passed and some address issues that are of concern relative to fair treatment of California residents such as pricing women’s personal care products higher than the equivalent product for men or stricter privacy regulations for online services and products accessed by kids under 18.

Laws and government exist to provide both security and freedom to citizens, often a delicate balance. For some of us, common sense and ethical, moral behavior precludes the need for many laws. However, it is a reality that many in our society either lack common sense or are not of the moral character to demonstrate acceptable behavior without the force of law. Even people who demonstrate common sense and strong moral character may have differing opinions on how society ought to operate. Here too, laws help guide the necessary compliance to achieve social cooperation.

Reviewing the laws that were passed in 2022, in some instances, laws have been passed that are essentially redundant to current laws and add bureaucracy and cost.  Such is the case with AB 257  and AB 1228 which create  a state run council that oversees wages, hours and working conditions for the fast food industry.  However, existing law provides for employee protection and the enforcement of labor laws under the Division of Occupational Safety and Health and the Division of Labor Standards and Enforcement. The law provides for the Council to develop standards, rules, wage levels and specify working conditions.  If these rules and regulations conflict with other government agencies, the other agency rules would have no effect on the fast-food workers. So rather than reviewing existing regulation to determine if any modification should be made, our state legislators develop an agency that essentially has parallel responsibilities to what already exists and creates more bureaucracy that cost taxpayers and businesses millions of dollars per year.

It is common for our legislators to revel in the number of bills they author. While this would seem to be a natural gauge of accomplishment, it is responsible for increased government spending resulting in higher taxes. In addition, complexity and bureaucracy in our daily lives continues to increase.

Regardless of political ideology, laws, regulations, and rules should be implemented in a responsible manner ensuring our tax dollars are spent efficiently. Too often, government laws and regulations are implemented without common sense due diligence or consideration of unintended consequences.

Redundancies and agency overlap as referenced above should be identified in the legislative process and not proceed. We need to require all legislation, regulations and rules be objectively assessed for their impact prior to approval and implementation.

It is apparent that our legislators often do not apply common sense in much of their law-making work. One way to address this inadequacy is to amend the California State Constitution under ARTICLE IV LEGISLATIVE [Sec 8 b] by adding provisions such as the following:

·         No bill may be passed until an objective, non-partisan assessment of its implications is completed.

·         Objective, non-partisan assessment must identify any current statute, regulation, or rule that which subject, in whole or in part, is embraced by current statute. Assessment will consider whether the existing statute should be modified or whether the new bill should be moved forward with amendments to subsume existing legislation. If the bill proceeds, recission of existing legislation would be included.

·         The assessment would also include identifying the responsible agency for implementation and management of the statute. No commission, agency or department will be created unless existing governmental structure is incapable of managing the stature with reasonable modification.

·         Assessments would be holistic and clearly articulate both positive and negative social, economic, and environmental impacts to segments of the population. Recommendations would be included that would balance granting rights with maintaining personal freedom.

An amendment like this could go a long way in requiring our representatives  to  be responsible to provide the efficiency and common sense in their legislation.

Wednesday, May 3, 2023

Reversing the Decline in Education Effectiveness.


Without question, the Covid-19 Pandemic negatively impacted education and student performance throughout the country.  Test scores  for 4th and 8th grade students from National Assessment of Educational Progress — known as the “nation’s report card” in math, reading, history and civics fell in some cases to an all time low. In all cases scores were below 2019, but in some cases the declines began before the pandemic. In the case of history, test scores have been in decline since 2014.  Of course, the states varied widely in the performance of their students. Explore test results by state and subject with this tool on the NAEP site.

Education is one of the most hotly discussed political topics. A myriad of reasons exist as to why the education of our children is suffering. Clearly the pandemic, school closures and remote learning seriously compromised learning effectiveness.  Critics point out students in states with extended pandemic lockouts fared worse than others. Students from single parent families where a parent could not work remotely and low-income students with no or limited access to the internet hampered remote learning. In some cases where civics and history are facing highly politicized debates over content teachers are avoiding discussion to avoid contention.  (Highly contentious subjects can be debated in a civil way as I did in a high school debate class defending the US role in Vietnam….it serves to discover facts and articulate opinions with substantiation)

So, all the above have no doubt contributed to the current situation. The question is what is to be done to address these issues and realize improvement.  One way to make a significant change is using AI, artificial intelligence.  While there is much trepidation in moving AI forward without proper “guard rails”, a position I firmly believe, there may be an incredibly effective role for AI to use in education.

Sal Khan, founder of the Khan Academy, is developing Khanmigo, a capability that provides an AI powered tutor for students and an AI powered teaching assistant for instructors that could very well be a game changer.

Take a few minutes to watch Sal’s TED talk on how Khan Academy is using AI.   I came away very impressed!