Of Course we all want to have financial security when we retire. Social security provides some level of income for those who have worked within the system and paid in throughout their career. No, it is not enough. However, many employers also have 401(k) savings plans and if those are not available, then IRAs are widely available. Yet many workers choose not to save for retirement. (I was amazed at the number of employees that did NOT participate in the 401(k) plan at one of the companies at which I worked).
So now the legislators in California want to further expand government's role by mandating that employers provide a state run retirement plan for those who have neglected to plan for their future.
- More mandates and expenses for California business, in this case, small business who currently may not be providing retirement plans
- Creation of yet more bureaucracy, the Golden State Retirement Savings Investment Board, which will have to be funded by either taxes or investment earnings
- Claim that the return would be guaranteed. As we all know financial investments always pose some level of risk.To guarantee a return implies either a subsidy if markets turn south or sub standard rates to provide a cushion should poor returns eventuate in a given period of time.
- The plan is portable from one California employer to another California employer but there is no provision for portability if the worker moves out of state
- California bureaucrats have already demonstrated their ineptitude at running a wide variety of services for the state's citizens. Shall we really entrust the savings of our citizens to the same sort of incompetence?
Think about the best in class organizations with which you have experience? Who is the best provider of service? Engenders trust and exudes competency? Provides responsive, helpful customer service? My guess is that there is no government agency on the list...not the DMV, Franchise Tax Board, etc.
The bottom line is that government is there to provide services that cannot be adequately performed by the private sector. This idea is so far off the mark it is ludicrous.
SB1234 has not yet gone to Assembly vote so Governor Brown has not yet signed this legislation. Contact your state assemblyman/woman and the Governor to voice your opposition of this law.