Wednesday, October 24, 2012

Reagan vs. Obama Social Economics 101


While the message is genuine and certainly my perspective, I just could not resist the caricatures in this video...tons of fun

Monday, October 22, 2012

Notes to preface the 3rd Presidential Debate focused on Foreign Policy

Before we get wrapped up in the predictable argument over the mishandling of the Benghazi attack, suffice it to say that Benghazi was not about foreign policy but rather about a fatal mistake in security tactics and political efforts to downplay the incident.  This is a case of poor execution rather than poor policy since  no one  believes any president would have a policy that would lead to leaving our diplomats vulnerable to attack.

If staged correctly, this debate should expose a number of  critical dimensions of the candidates positions:

  1. What should the US  position be relative to a number of foreign policy issues including:
    • Iran and nuclear weapons
    • Civil strife in foreign countries like Syria
    • Trade issues with China
  2. How should the US implement  actions and When does the US engage militarily?
  3. Is the US the world's policeman?
  4. How does the US build and maintain its global credibility?
We need to understand how the US would behave under the leadership of each candidate. Clearly both candidates will staunchly defend the security of the US, but how are the key international issues to be navigated so that the US remains respected and influential in the global scheme of things?

Wednesday, October 17, 2012

Taxes and American Corporation - Part 2

Both Presidential candidates have spoken about the need to lower the US corporate tax rate. In addition, there has been talk about how US companies have exported jobs and much rhetoric about how we need to bring jobs back to the US.What is lacking is the concrete plan to do so....so here's one:

Currently, US companies control $1.7 trillion in foreign earnings held outside the US. In order to bring this money back to US, companies would have to pay the IRS the US tax rate (already high at 35%) less what the company already paid in the foreign country. So their response is to leave the money abroad and since they have availability to these funds why not invest in the business abroad. The net result is the creation of jobs abroad rather than in the US.

Since 95% of the world's consumers live outside the US, it makes sense that vast revenues are generated internationally. Those revenues are taxed in the geography in which they are generated. Every other G-8 country uses what is called a territorial tax system where sales in foreign markets are taxed at the local market rate.Remaining funds then can be repatriated.

The US uses a worldwide tax system which was created in 1913 when the world's economy and business reach was very different. This approach has now led to corporate behaviors which harm rather than help the US economic recovery. The US should change the tax law and allow companies to repatriate their funds to energize investment in US business.

Taxes and the American Corporation- Part 1

It is somewhat baffling to me why in all the debates regarding taxes that a couple of points are not made by the Romney campaign.  If my understanding is correct, both would go a long way to setting the facts straight and stimulating job growth. Instead we continually hear half truths fabricated facts from the candidates. So let's straightened a bit of this out.

Taxes on dividends and long term capital gains are currently at 15%. Taxes on ordinary income range from 10% to 35%. In addition, there is a myriad of deductions and exemptions which can off ordinary income such as charitable contributions, mortgage interest, dependent deductions etc. Tax calculations and returns are very complicated and one needs to be cautious is citing effective tax rates on an individual's return.

Romney reportedly paid 14% Federal income tax on his 2011 earnings causing an outrage that he paid "less" than a secretary or a warehouseman. He did not pay less but his tax rate may have been less when the tax paid was figured as a percentage of his total income.  How can that be? Well first he, as are all of us, entitled to calculate our federal income tax based on the tax code. This will provide deductions and exemption that reduce the amount of tax paid. Second, certain income such as long term capital gains and dividends are taxed at a lower tax rate of 15%...again, outrage that that these "rich" people should pay more tax. But let's look at the rationale for the lower tax rates on capital gains and dividends.

The rationale of a lower tax rate for capital gains is somehwhat subjective. The notion is that anyone investing in a business or other investment over an extended length of time is taking on a risk to help the economy grow and therefore can be rewarded in part with a lower tax rate. Back in 1960 the average length of time a stock was held was 8 years; today it is 4 months. But any profits generated on an investment in less that 1 year is taxed as regular income.  Maintaining the lower capital gains tax helps fund businesses to grow and create jobs.

If we look at dividends, there is a completely different rationale. In fact, a case can be made that dividends should not be taxed at all because they are, in part, what is left over after a corporation has already been taxed.  Shareholders of any corporations are owners. Any dividends they receive flow from the profits after all expenses are paid. So the notion that dividends should be taxed as regular income clearly is a case of double taxation. So anyone who does receive dividends should understand that he/she already paid the tax of the corporations profit and to do so again is ....well, dare I say unfair!


Tuesday, October 9, 2012

Fixing Public Education in California

Next month when we go to the  polls here in California, we will be asked to vote on two "competing" propositions:

  • Proposition 30 would increase income taxes on those making over $250,000 per year and raise state sales tax by 1/4 cent. Proceeds from these increases are to be used for education and guarantee public safety funding
  • Proposition 38 would increase state income tax on a sliding scale with higher income earners bearing a higher percentage increase.
The first question to ask is why are there two competing propositions. The simple answer is that the Legislature in California has failed to manage the government effectively so these initiatives have been put forth in an attempt to solve problems that our elected officials are incapable of solving. There are two propositions addressing fundamentally the same thing because Governor Brown sees that education is in trouble in the state as are many other areas so in backing Prop 30, he gets needed funds but keeps a good bit of latitude where he spends the dollars...ie. say it is for education but spend in other areas.  Proposition 38 is the work of Molly Munger who is squarely addressing education problem in California by concluding that we need to throw more money at it. While obviously well intended, it  treats the symptoms not the source of California's public education problems.

There are approximately 6.2 million students enrolled in the California public schools comprising 1042 school districts. Average salary for teachers in California was $67,871 in 2011. This is 122% of the national average. The average revenue per registered student in 2011 was $11,285 which was 29th in the nation.
The average expenditure per student in 2011 was $9,313 which is 37th out of all the US. In addition, California has the highest average of students to teachers in the nation at 23.6. So without a doubt, California could spend more on education.

However, California ranks 12th in state and local taxes per capita. It is number 16 out of 50 states for the most spent on all government expenses. It spends the third most per capita in Corrections; 3rd in Police and Fire Protection; 21st in Welfare; 12th in Health and Hospitals; 45th in highways; and 11th in interest on debt.

So while the state appears to be coming up short for education spending, it already collects among the top 20% per capita in the country. It is a matter of where it spends the money (hint-one of the most powerful unions in CA is the California Correctional Peace Officers Association). In addition to setting better priorities, the California edcuation system has to deal with an enormous student population which are not native English speakers adding to the challenge in the classroom. It is time we take a fresh look at where and how the money is spend in California schools. It is time to streamline the administrative infrastructure. We need to reward the good teachers and retrain or dump those who are ineffective.Education is extremely importand and should get the support of the state's residents but along with that comes the responsibility to deliver best in class education services. 

Take a look at this WSJ article on "The Imaginary Teacher Shortage"


(N.B. All statistics regarding education and government spending are from the National Education Association "Ranking & Estimates- December 2011"

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Debate Focuses on the "How"

Growing up my parents would frequently reminded me  to "get along" with others, be positive and look for the good in situations (eg. the glass is half full not half empty), stand up for what you believe in, etc. As I entered the business world, it was very clear that making the right decisions not necessarily the popular ones, collaborating effectively with co-workers, taking responsibility and diligent work all contribute to success. People who are highly critical, quick to assign blame, avoid work and shirk responsibility generally do not succeed in productive organizations.

It is a quite unfortunate that today's youth see the two people running for the most powerful job in the world demonstrating behaviors for which we would chastise our children. To date, the primary platform of both candidates is one of criticism and blame of their opponent. So it was interesting to see that the Presidential debates took a bit different turn. The two candidates appeared much more civil and respectful than their campaigns would have indicated.

That said...it seems the hallmark of today's successful politician seems to be how good of a liar he/she is...or at least what part of the truth to withhold to create the desire perception while all along supporting a different agenda.  With Mr. Obama he seemed to dwell on information regarding Romney's proposed tax cuts which was suspect and, in fact, denied several times. To me this indicates selectively choosing information, regardless of its veracity, to prove a point.

On the other hand, Mr. Romney acknowledged some of what was accomplished under Obama's administration was in the right direction but reflected the ideals of "big government" knowing how to better solve problems that the creative citizens of the US....a point that is right on with common sense approach to running a country. This alone should be indicative of Romney's skill to work collaboratively to get the nation back on track.

In my perspective, both candidates want much the same thing. The difference is not the "what" but the "how". While we have seen the "how" of Obama (including his moves to side step constitutional governance to advance his own agenda) we may be less familiar with the "how"  with Romney. However, judging from his success in business and tenure as Massachusetts governor, he portrays a return to the common sense of government we all need.