Monday, April 19, 2021

California Climate Program Gone Awry

 

The following email message was sent to me by Pacific Gas & Electric on behalf of the California Public Utilities Commission

This April* your utility bill will include a credit identified as the “California Climate Credit.” Your household and millions of others throughout the state will receive this credit on your utility bills.

The California Climate Credit is part of California’s efforts to fight climate change. This credit is from a state program that requires power plants, natural gas providers, and other large industries that emit greenhouse gases to buy carbon pollution permits. The credit on your bill is your share of the payments from the State’s program.

 Although a credit on my utility bill is certainly welcome, I became a bit perplexed as to why I was getting a credit on my utility bill from the company that has been proven to have an inadequate power delivery infrastructure that has caused devastating wildfires and caused extended power shut offs to reduce the chance of causing more fires. 

According to the California Air Resources Board (CARB) funds for this credit come from the carbon permit auction proceeds California Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund. Since its inception in 2013, proceeds through February of 2021 total $14,880,541,796.  (California Air Resources Board February 2021 California Post Joint Auction Public Proceeds Report)

In addition to the above, over $5.1 billion have been returned to California utility rate payers in the form of a climate credit. (https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/climatecredit/)

So, with all this investment, I was curious as to the impact the Carbon Reduction program was having in California.  According to CARB, CO2 emissions in 2013 were 447.7 million metric tons (MMT CO2e).  In 2018, (latest date available - https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/ghg-inventory-data)  CO2e emissions were 425.4 MMT CO2e.  The 2020 GHG emissions limit is 431 (MMTCO2e). Despite the 3 % population growth in the state, CO2 emissions are down 22.3 MMT CO2e/year or about 5%. So, things are moving the right direction.

While program appears to have improved the CO2 situation, the California wildfires surely must have tipped the scale the other way. But just a hunch was not good enough; I needed facts.

Going back to the CARB (https://ww3.arb.ca.gov/cc/inventory/pubs/wildfire_emissions_faq.pdf) the 2020 CO2 emissions estimate due to wildfires was 112 (MMTCO2)!  This is 8 times the 20-year average emissions due to wildfires. And 25% of the total CO2 emitted by the entire state.

We need to reset priorities of how the GGRF proceeds are invested. Sure, there are lots of beneficial programs like public and alternative transportation, solar panels for low-income housing and wet land restoration. However, any emission improvement of these sorts of programs is mere rounding error to the amount of CO2 emitted by wildfires. Some programs like Climate Credit utility rebates do nothing but create a “feel good” occasion for politicians. 

Had much more of the $14 billion been spent on hardening the electricity infrastructure and forest management, the CO2 emission reduction would have been an order of magnitude better. Not to mention that the 4 million acres of vegetation that was burned in California potentially could absorb 8-10 MMT CO2e.

The question is does anyone in Sacramento understand this reality and care enough to do something about it???